i recently pulled out "pat the bunny" for benjamin and he loves it! i kind of forgot about it because i hate to admit i am not as good about reading to benjamin as i was with samuel. we had to buy a new "pat the bunny" for benjamin because samuel chewed on his and it wasn't a complete book anymore. after only reading it to benjamin a few times and showing him what to do, he is starting to do it himself. i love "pat the bunny"!